Benchmarking of Synthetic Network Data: Reviewing Challenges and Approaches

The development of Network Intrusion Detection Systems (NIDS) requires labeled network traffic, especially to train and evaluate machine learning approaches. Besides the recording of traffic, the generation of traffic via generative models is a promising approach to obtain vast amounts of labeled data. There exist various machine learning approaches for data generation, but the assessment of the data quality is complex and not standardized. The lack of common quality criteria complicates the comparison of synthetic data generation approaches and synthetic data.Our work addresses this gap in multiple steps. Firstly, we review and categorize existing approaches for evaluating synthetic data in the network traffic domain and other data domains as well. Secondly, based on our review, we compile a setup of metrics that are suitable for the NetFlow domain, which we aggregate into two metrics Data Dissimilarity Score and Domain Dissimilarity Score. Thirdly, we evaluate the proposed metrics on real world data sets, to demonstrate their ability to distinguish between samples from different data sets. As a final step, we conduct a case study to demonstrate the application of the metrics for the evaluation of synthetic data. We calculate the metrics on samples from real NetFlow data sets to define an upper and lower bound for inter- and intra-data set similarity scores. Afterward, we generate synthetic data via Generative Adversarial Network (GAN) and Generative Pre-trained Transformer 2 (GPT-2) and apply the metrics to these synthetic data and incorporate these lower bound baseline results to obtain an objective benchmark. The application of the benchmarking process is demonstrated on three NetFlow benchmark data sets, NF-CSE-CIC-IDS2018, NF-ToN-IoT and NF-UNSW-NB15. Our demonstration indicates that this benchmark framework captures the differences in similarity between real world data and synthetic data of varying quality well, and can therefore be used to assess the quality of generated synthetic data.