Luxury application of biochar does not enhance rice yield and methane mitigation: a review and data analysis

Purpose It is unclear whether a higher biochar (BC) application rate enhances rice (Oryza sativa L.) yield and reduces CH4 emissions. This study investigated changes in rice yield and CH4 emissions with varying BC application rates.Methods Data on rice yield and CH4 emission from paddies amended with or without BC were collected from the literature, and the biochar effects were analyzed using the data set.Results Across the biochar application rate from 2 to 48 t ha-1, the rice yield increased (by 10.8%) while the area-scaled (by 14.4%) and yield-scaled CH4 emission (by 22.2%) decreased. However, the correlation of BC application rates with rice yield and CH4 mitigation was not significant, implying that a higher BC application rate did not enhance rice yield and CH4 reduction. Interestingly, for a data set showing increased rice yield and decreased CH4 emission by BC, the magnitude of change in the rice yield and CH4 mitigation per unit weight of BC (1 t ha-1) decreased with an increase in the BC application rate. These results suggest that BC effects on rice yield and CH4 mitigation are not additive, probably because of the decreases in the inherent capacity of unit weight of BC to enhance rice yield and reduce CH4 emission, which might be caused by the adverse effects of toxic compounds contained in BC, losses of BC, and a higher degree of nutrient immobilization by BC.Conclusions Annual BC application at a low rate (e.g., 2 t ha-1) rather than a luxury application may be an effective and economical strategy for long-term rice yield enhancement and CH4 mitigation using BC.