Comparison of cerebral safety following atrial fibrillation using pulsed field and thermal ablation: Results of the Neurological Assessment Subgroup in the ADVENT Trial

Background Atrial fibrillation (AF) ablation carries the risk of silent cerebral event (SCE) and silent cerebral lesion (SCL). Though "silent," these may have long-term clinical implications and are challenging to study as post-procedural MRI is not standard-of-care. Objective The neurological assessment subgroup (NAS) of ADVENT compared cerebral effects of pulsed field ablation (PFA) to standard-of-care thermal ablation. Methods The NAS included consecutive randomized PFA and thermal ablation patients who received post-procedural brain MRI 12-48 hours post-ablation. Patients with apparent SCE or SCL findings underwent a modified Rankin Scale (mRS) assessment. MRI images were subsequently reviewed by a blinded Brain Imaging Core Laboratory. Results In total, 77 patients with paroxysmal AF were enrolled at 6 centers; 71 had analyzable scans (34 PFA; 37 thermal ablation). Through individual center review, 6 PFA and 4 thermal scans were identified as SCE/SCL positive, of which, 3 PFA and 0 thermal SCE/SCL findings were confirmed by a blinded core laboratory. MRI findings revealed one patient with 2-4mm SCEs, one patient with a 3mm SCE, and one patient with 2 SCLs (5.5mm and 11mm). All mRS and NIHSS scores were 0 prior to discharge and at 90-day follow-up. There were only two neurological safety events (1 TIA (PFA) and 1 stroke (thermal) in the ADVENT study, neither of which was part of the NAS. Conclusions The ADVENT trial provides the first prospective, randomized data on the cerebral impact of PFA and thermal ablation of AF. Incidence of SCE/SCLs following ablation in the NAS was low.