Summer cover crop and temporary legume-cereal intercrop effects on soil microbial indicators, soil water and cash crop yields in a semi-arid environment

Context Few studies have investigated summer cover crops as a replacement for bare fallow in semi-arid temperate regions, and summer cover crop impacts on soil biological function, water balances and subsequent winter crop yields in these regions remain largely unknown. Objective The 4-year field study aimed to determine the consequences of replacing a summer fallow with a summer growing cover crop on soil function, water balances and subsequent winter cash crop yields in a semi-arid region (486 mm mean annual rainfall) of the Australian southern cropping zone. Methods A canola (Brassica napus)-wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) rotation with summer fallow was compared to the same rotation with either i) a single species (buckwheat, Fagopyrum esculentum L.) summer cover crop; ii) a four-species mixed brassica + cereal summer cover crop or iii) a cropping sequence with a temporary legume intercrop in the wheat phase of the rotation. Cover crop biomass production, soil water to a depth of 90 cm at cash crop sowing, crop yields and soil functional indices were quantified. Results Cover crops produced 500–700 kg biomass ha−1 in the 2020 and 2021 seasons and 1000–2400 kg biomass ha−1 in 2022. The four-species mixed cover crop significantly lowered soil water (around 30 mm; P < 0.05) at the time of sowing the cash crop compared to the control and resulted in 15% reduction (P = 0.12) in canola seed yield in 2020, but no significant effect of cover crops of soil water and mineral N at sowing, or cash crop yields, were observed in subsequent seasons. In 2021 the temporary vetch intercrop produced > 1000 kg ha−1 biomass over 9 weeks, and led to a (non-significant) 10% wheat yield reduction. There was no significant effect of cover crop or temporary intercrop treatments on soil functions in the 2020 or 2021 seasons, but activities of several soil enzymes (leucine aminopeptidase, arylsulfatase and B-glucosidase; P < 0.05) and water-soluble carbon (P = 0.059) were significantly higher in the summer cover crop plots compared to control and intercrop plots in March 2022 following termination of the cover crops. These changes coincided with a significant increase in saturated hydraulic conductivity in the four-species cover crop plots in March 2022 compared to control plots. Implications The study did not provide any compelling evidence for benefits of summer cover crops over fallow in the short term (3–4 years). The relatively low cover crop biomass production over the 4-year study suggests summer cover crops are unlikely to substantially improve soil carbon levels in temperate, semi-arid cropping systems.