Effects of different reclamation measures on soil quality restoration in open-pit mines: A meta-analysis based on the Chinese Loess Plateau

In the Loess Plateau region, ecological restoration projects have been implemented to restore the ecological environment of open-pit mines. However, no consistent conclusion has been reached regarding the response of soil remediation efforts to different ecological measures and restoration years. A meta-analysis was performed on the results of studies published over the past 30 years for open-pit mining areas on the Loess Plateau in China. The findings reveal that land rehabilitation considerably improved soil quality in open-pit mining areas on the Loess Plateau. Different ecological measures revealed a significant variability in soil quality restoration. Specifically, forestland reclamation affected soil organic matter and microbial carbon the most. Grassland reclamation substantially influenced soil total potassium, organic carbon, enzyme activity, and microbial abundance. Plowland caused the most effective improvement in soil total nitrogen and physical properties. However, total phosphorus and pH were unaffected by restoration measures. In addition, the period of land reclamation and soil nutrients showed a high correlation in the early stage of reclamation. After long-term reclamation, a decreased rate of soil quality improvement by remediation measures occurred after the soil quality returned to its premining level. A relatively lag was observed in the response of soil microbial indicators to environmental changes, and the premining level was reached after longer-term reclamation.