Human activities caused lake ecological transitions in the Chinese Loess Plateau over the past 1400 years

The combined effects of climate change and human disturbance has degraded lake ecosystems worldwide in recent times, but there are few studies that explore the relative impact of these factors over long timescales. In this paper, we use sedimentary pigment data to reveal variations in algal abundance and the lake ecological environment of a typical subalpine lake (Beilianchi Lake) in the southwestern Chinese Loess Plateau, to distinguish the relative effects of natural climate change and human disturbance over the past 5000 years. Our data show that between 5000 and 1400 cal yr BP, algal abundance exhibited a slow decline without obvious fluctuations, mainly driven by a gradually drying and cooling climate. After 1400 cal yr BP, algal abundance showed large and rapid fluctuations characterized by a pattern of a decline, then increase, and then decline again. During this period, human activities began to affect lake ecology and gradually overshadowed the role of climatic changes as the main driving factor. Enhanced human disturbances caused a rapid and synchronous decline in algal abundance due to increases in soil erosion and reductions in water transparency. Algal biomass levels recovered when the soil erosion intensity decreased during 1400–500 cal yr BP corresponding to the period from Song to Yuan Dynasties. Thereafter (during the period of Ming and Qing Dynasties), as human activities became further enhanced and the soil erosion intensity became very high, the lake ecosystem rapidly transitioned to a stable state of low algal growth. This indicates that the lake ecosystem may have had the capacity to recover from moderate external disturbances in the early stages of human activity, but the resilience of the lake ecosystem began to decrease under stronger human disturbances. Our findings provide important empirical evidence for evaluating the current state of lakes and for sound lake management in the future.