Phase-preserving narrow- and wide-angle parabolic equations for sound propagation in moving media

Parabolic equations are among the most popular numerical techniques in many fields of physics. This article considers extra-wide-angle parabolic equations, wide-angle parabolic equations, and narrow-angle parabolic equations (EWAPEs, WAPEs, and NAPEs, respectively) for sound propagation in moving inhomogeneous media with arbitrarily large variations in the sound speed and Mach number of the (subsonic) wind speed. Within their ranges of applicability, these parabolic equations exactly describe the phase of the sound waves and are, thus, termed the phase-preserving EWAPE, WAPE, and NAPE. Although variations in the sound speed and Mach number are often relatively small, omitting the second-order terms pertinent to these quantities can result in large cumulative phase errors for long propagation ranges. Therefore, the phase-preserving EWAPE, WAPE, and NAPE can be preferable in applications. Numerical implementation of the latter two equations can be performed with minimal modifications to existing codes and is computationally efficient. Numerical results demonstrate that the phase-preserving WAPE and NAPE provide more accurate results than the WAPE and NAPE based on the effective sound speed approximation.