MusiKeys: Exploring Haptic-to-Auditory Sensory Substitution to Improve Mid-Air Text-Entry.

Physical QWERTY keyboards are the current standard for performing precision text-entry with extended reality devices. Ideally, there would exist a comparable, self-contained solution that works anywhere, without requiring external keyboards. Unfortunately, when physical keyboards are recreated virtually, we currently lose critical haptic feedback information from the sense of touch, which impedes typing. In this paper, we introduce the MusiKeys Technique, which uses auditory feedback in virtual reality to communicate missing haptic feedback information typists normally receive when using a physical keyboard. To examine this concept, we conducted a user study with 24 participants which encompassed four mid-air virtual keyboards augmented with increasing amounts of feedback information, along with a fifth physical keyboard for reference. Results suggest that providing clicking feedback on key-press and key-release improves typing performance compared to not providing auditory feedback, which is consistent with the literature. We also found that audio can serve as a substitute for information contained in haptic feedback, in that users can accurately perceive the presented information. However, under our specific study conditions, this awareness of the feedback information did not yield significant differences in typing performance. Our results suggest this kind of feedback replacement can be perceived by users but needs more research to tune and improve the specific techniques.