Divergent genetic landscapes drive lower levels of AmpC induction and stable de-repression in Serratia marcescens compared to Enterobacter cloacae

The chromosomally encoded AmpC beta-lactamase is widely distributed throughout the Enterobacterales. When expressed at high levels through transient induction or stable de-repression, resistance to ceftriaxone, a commonly used antibiotic, can develop. Recent clinical guidance suggests, based on limited evidence, that resistance may be less likely to develop in Serratia marcescens compared to the better-studied Enterobacter cloacae and recommends that ceftriaxone may be used if the clinical isolate tests susceptible. We sought to generate additional data relevant to this recommendation. AmpC de-repression occurs predominantly because of mutation in the ampD peptidoglycan amidohydrolase. We find that, in contrast to E. cloacae, where deletion of ampD results in high-level ceftriaxone resistance (with ceftriaxone MIC = 96 mu g/mL), in S. marcescens deletion of two amidohydrolases (ampD and amiD2) is necessary for AmpC de-repression, and the resulting ceftriaxone MIC is 1 mu g/mL. Two mechanisms for this difference were identified. We find both a higher relative increase in ampC transcript level in E. cloacae Delta ampD compared to S. marcescens Delta ampD Delta amiD2, as well as higher in vivo efficiency of ceftriaxone hydrolysis by the E. cloacae AmpC enzyme compared to the S. marcescens AmpC enzyme. We also observed higher relative levels of transient AmpC induction in E. cloacae vs S. marcescens when exposed to ceftriaxone. In time-kill curves, this difference translates into the survival of E. cloacae but not S. marcescens at clinically relevant ceftriaxone concentrations. In summary, our findings can explain the decreased propensity for on-treatment ceftriaxone resistance development in S. marcescens, thereby supporting recently issued clinical guidance.