Effects of Movement Induced by Ground Improvement on the Performance of an Excavation Support System in Underconsolidated Clay

The recent construction of an underground mass rapid transit (MRT) station in Singapore involved 21 m deep excavations within underconsolidated marine clay. The lateral earth support system comprised 1 m thick diaphragm walls socketed into the underlying Old Alluvium and 4 levels of preloaded cross-lot struts. Deep soil mixing (DSM) and jet grouting piles (JGP) were used to improve up to 15 m thickness of the marine clay formation. Field monitoring data showed that these ground improvement processes caused large outward deflections of the diaphragm wall panels at some locations prior to the excavation and may have caused yielding within the wall panels. In this paper, the impacts of these prior wall deformations on the subsequent performance of the excavation support system are investigated. The measured performance at two indicative cross sections is compared with results from simplified 2D finite element analyses. The analyses simulate the effects of ground improvement through prescribed boundary pressures and represent the yielding of the diaphragm wall panels through zones of reduced bending stiffness. We show that large outward wall deflections and curvature observed during jet grouting at one section contribute to higher inward wall movements and strut loads measured during excavation, while smaller movements (and curvature) prior to excavation at a second similar cross section cause negligible change in the performance of the temporary earth retaining system. The results highlight (1) the importance of controlling ground movements associated with ground modification processes such as jet grouting, (2) the uncertainties in estimating mechanical properties for the improved soil mass, and (3) the need to improve the representation of non-linear, flexural properties (M-kappa) of reinforced concrete diaphragm panels.