Real-Life Effectiveness of Smoking Cessation Delivery Modes: A Comparison Against Telephone Counseling and the Role of Individual Characteristics and Health Conditions in Quit Success

Introduction Professional behavioral counseling for smoking cessation can be delivered in many forms, which may not work equally well for everyone. We aim to explore in a real-world setting whether different delivery modes yield different rates of quit success and whether quit success varies based on gender, age, educational level, and being treated for a health condition.Aims and Methods We used monitoring data (n = 13 747) from a smoking cessation counseling provider in the Netherlands (September 2018 to August 2021) to compare differences in quit success immediately after the end of counseling and at 12-month follow-up between telephone and other modes of counseling. Participants chose which mode of counseling they received. At the 12-month follow-up, we also examined differences in quit success based on demographic characteristics and whether one is being treated for various health conditions.Results Participants of in-person group counseling and online in-company group counseling were significantly more likely to have quit immediately after the counseling compared with telephone counseling (OR = 1.25, 95% CI = 1.08-1.44; OR = 1.63, 95% CI = 1.18-2.24). Analyses revealed no significant differences in quit success between telephone and other modes of counseling after 12 months. Those treated for a respiratory or psychological condition were less likely to have maintained quit success, as were women, and participants with a lower educational level.Conclusions When chosen by oneself, the mode of smoking cessation counseling received does not appear to be important for long-term quit success. However, certain groups warrant extra support to prevent excessive program attrition and unsuccessful quit attempts.Implications Our findings suggest that when chosen by oneself, the delivery mode of smoking cessation counseling does not appear to be important for long-term quit success. This finding is of particular relevance for those who are unable to attend in-person cessation counseling due to, for instance, reduced accessibility or mobility. We also found that women, lower educated, and younger participants were more likely to dropout of the cessation program or to not have maintained a quit attempt, signaling that disparities in smoking cessation persist when standardized counseling is given, and therefore more tailored counseling may be necessary for these groups.