Green Additive Limits Runaway Crystallinity in PM6:Y6 Organic Solar Cells but Causes Field-Independent Geminate Recombination

Solvent additives are well-established for improving device performance of organic solar cells by enhancing nanodomain phase separation and crystallization. However, optimum additive concentrations are typically at trace amounts with slight fluctuations causing runaway crystallinity that short the device and limit scale-up potential. Here we show that a nonhalogenated solvent additive 1-phenylnaphthalene (PN) can be used to optimize high-performance PM6:Y6 devices, but without runaway crystallinity even at concentrations 10x above the optimum. Our holistic analysis of device losses shows that PN increases photoabsorption while decreasing bimolecular recombination. However, above the optimum, charge generation is reduced due to field-independent geminate recombination of charge transfer states that overcomes the other benefits. Rotated Y6 crystallite orientation is a likely culprit, where the device electric field is ineffective at separating the charges. Despite this, device performance remains higher than that of traditional additives, indicating a route to avoiding the high sensitivity of performance to processing conditions.