The Haptic Intensity Order Illusion Is Caused by Amplitude Changes

When two brief vibrotactile stimulations are sequentially applied to observers' lower back, there is systematic mislocalization of the stimulation: if the second stimulation is of higher intensity than the first one, observers tend to respond that the second stimulation was above the first one, and vice versa when weak intensity stimulation follows a strong one. This haptic mislocalization effect has been called the intensity order illusion. In the original demonstration of the illusion, frequency and amplitude of the stimulation were inextricably linked so that changes in amplitude also resulted in changes in frequency. It is therefore unknown whether the illusion is caused by changes in frequency, amplitude or both. To test this, we performed a multifactorial experiment, where we used L5 actuators that allow independent manipulation of frequency and amplitude. This approach enabled us to investigate the effects of stimulus amplitude, frequency and location, and to assess any potential interactions among these factors. We report four main findings: (1) we were able to replicate the intensity order illusion with the L5 tactors; (2) the illusionmainly occurred in the upwards direction, or in other words, when strong stimulation following a weaker one occurred above or in the same location as the first stimulation; (3) the illusion did not occur when similar stimulation patterns were applied in the horizontal direction; and (4) the illusion was solely due to changes in amplitude, whereas changes in frequency (100 Hz vs 200 Hz) had no effect.