Evaluating Fracture Surface Imaging Methods Using Flow Simulations and Air Permeameter Measurements

Knowledge of fracture properties and associated flow processes is important for geoscience applications such as nuclear waste disposal, geothermal energy and hydrocarbons. An important tool established in recent years are hydro-mechanical models which provide a useful alternative to experimental methods determining single fracture parameters such as hydraulic aperture. A crucial issue for meaningful numerical modeling is precise imaging of the fracture surfaces to capture geometrical information. Hence, we apply and compare three distinct fracture surface imaging methods: (1) handheld laser scanner (HLS), (2) mounted laser scanner (MLS) and (3) Structure from Motion (SfM) to a bedding plane fracture of sandstone. The imaging reveals that the resolution of the fracture surface obtained from handheld laser scanner (HLS) is insufficient for any numerical simulations, which was therefore rejected. The remaining surfaces are subsequently matched and the resulting fracture dataset is used for detailed fracture flow simulations. The resulting hydraulic aperture is calibrated with laboratory measurements using a handheld air permeameter. The air permeameter data provide a hydraulic aperture of 81 ± 1 µm. For calibration, mechanical aperture fields are calculated using stepwise increasing contact areas up to 15%. At 5% contact area, the average hydraulic aperture obtained by MLS (85 µm) is close to the measurement. For SfM, the measurements are fitted at 7% contact area (83 µm). The flow simulations reveal preferential flow through major channels that are structurally and geometrically predefined. Thus, this study illustrates that resolution and accuracy of the imaging device strongly affect the quality of fluid flow simulations and that SfM provides a promising low-cost method for fracture imaging on cores or even outcrops.