Origin of symmetry breaking in the grasshopper model

The planar grasshopper problem, originally introduced by Goulko and Kent [Proc. R. Soc. A 473, 20170494 (2017)], is a striking example of a model with long-range isotropic interactions whose ground states break rotational symmetry. In this paper we analyze and explain the nature of this symmetry breaking with emphasis on the importance of dimensionality. Interestingly, rotational symmetry is recovered in three dimensions for small jumps, which correspond to the nonisotropic cogwheel regime of the two-dimensional problem. We discuss simplified models that reproduce the symmetry properties of the original system in N dimensions. For the full grasshopper model in two dimensions we obtain quantitative predictions for optimal perturbations of the disk. Our analytical results are confirmed by numerical simulations.