Inter-virus relationships in mixed infections and virus-drought relationships in plants: a quantitative review

Inter-virus relationships in mixed infections and virus-drought relationships are important in agriculture and natural vegetation. In this quantitative review, we sampled published factorial experiments to probe for relationships against the null hypothesis of additivity. Our sample captured antagonistic, additive and synergistic inter-virus relationships in double infections. Virus-drought relationships in our sample were additive or antagonistic, reinforcing the notion that viruses have neutral or positive effects on droughted plants, or that drought enhances plant tolerance to viruses. Both inter-virus and virus-drought relationships vary with virus species, host plant to the level of cultivar or accession, timing of infection, plant age and trait and growing conditions. The trait-dependence of these relationships has implications for resource allocation in plants. Owing to lagging theories, more experimental research in these fields is bound to return phenomenological outcomes. Theoretical work can advance in two complementary directions. First, the effective theory models the behaviour of the system without specifying all the underlying causes that lead to system state change. Second, mechanistic theory based on a nuanced view of the plant phenotype that explicitly considers downward causation; the influence of the plant phenotype on inter-virus relations and vice versa; the impact of timing, intensity and duration of drought interacting with viruses to modulate the plant phenotype; both the soil (moisture) and atmospheric (vapour pressure deficit) aspects of drought. Theories should scale in time, from short term to full growing season, and in levels of organisation up to the relevant traits: crop yield in agriculture and fitness in nature. Inter-virus and virus-drought relationships in plants have been the subject of narrative reviews. Here we quantify these relationships against the null hypothesis of additivity. Inter-virus relationships spanned from antagonistic to additive and synergistic, and virus-drought relationships from antagonistic to additive. Both relationships vary with virus species, host plant to the level of cultivar or accession, timing of infection, plant age and trait and growing conditions. Owing to lagging theories, further experimental research in these fields is bound to return phenomenological outcomes, with results lacking contextualised interpretability.