A maladaptive parental effect: offspring survival decreases with maternal over-condition in an amphibian

Parental effects are often considered an evolved response, in which parents transmit information about the environment to enhance offspring fitness. However, these effects need not be adaptive. Here, we provide a striking example by presenting evidence that overfeeding of adult Mexican spadefoot toads, Spea multiplicata, is associated with decreased offspring survival. After a temporary change to their standard feeding regimen, S. multiplicata in our captive colony developed a much higher body condition (i.e. body mass for a given body length) than those in the wild. We analysed data from three subsequent experiments and found that although the body condition of a father was positively correlated with tadpole survival, mothers with a higher condition had lower tadpole survival. Our study highlights how obesity can negatively impact future generations via maladaptive maternal effects. Such effects could be especially likely for animals living in variable environments (such as spadefoots) that have evolved 'thrifty phenotypes' that make them prone to obesity. Our study also illustrates how husbandry conditions typically regarded as beneficial might be harmful. Given that captive breeding programmes are increasingly used to combat worldwide amphibian declines, these programmes must consider the ecology and evolutionary history of the focal species to minimize any maladaptive parental effects.