Raman spectroscopy for real-time concurrent detection of multiple scalants on RO membranes

In-situ monitoring techniques of reverse osmosis (RO) desalination systems, particularly those with chemical sensing capabilities, can provide the means for better understanding important scaling mechanisms as well as early scaling detection. In this work, both calcium sulfate and calcium carbonate scaling on RO membranes were detected concurrently in real time using Raman spectroscopy to provide a unique chemical fingerprint. Two different sampling methodologies (manual and automated) were employed, and their performance was evaluated by comparing the Raman detection times to concurrent values of flux decline. The manual sampling strategy resulted in the detection of calcium sulfate and calcium carbonate at mean permeate flux declines of 13 ± 10 % and 22 ± 3 %, respectively. The automated sampling strategy provided better performance, with detection of calcium sulfate and calcium carbonate at mean flux declines of 8 ± 5 % and 4 ± 3 %, respectively. The increased sensitivity and decreased variability of the automated sampling strategy provided valuable preliminary insights for the selection of optimized sampling strategies. The ability to identify the chemical composition of different scaling crystals including their polymorphs is an important step toward better understanding of the crystallization pathways of multi-component feed streams used in seawater and brackish water RO desalination.