The inner ear of caviomorph rodents: Phylogenetic implications and application to extinct West Indian taxa

With their past and current diversities, West Indian caviomorph rodents dominate the terrestrial mammalian fauna of the Caribbean archipelago. Many of these species have recently become extinct, including the emblematic giant forms known as Heptaxodontidae. The higher-level systematics and content of this family have been widely disputed over the last decades (i.e., membership in Cavioidea vs. Chinchilloidea vs. Octodontoidea). Here we analyzed the phylogenetic signal provided by several characters of the caviomorph inner ear to adress the phylogenetic affinities of the West Indian heptaxodontids. For this, we assembled an exhaustive taxonomic sampling ( N = 100) of extant North and South American caviomorphs (including representatives of all families) and a wide array of West Indian forms among octodontoid echimyids (extant and extinct capromyines, as well as extinct heteropsomyines), and some heptaxodontid subfossil taxa such as Amblyrhiza , Clidomys , and Elasmodontomys . Geometric morphometrics and comparative phylogenetic methods were employed to explore shape differences of the inner ear and their potential systematic implications. Our results show that: (1) allometry is a major contributor to shape variation in the bony labyrinth; (2) shape variation bears a strong phylogenetic signal, providing diagnostic characters for Caviidae and Erethizontoidea; and (3) Amblyrhiza and Clidomys are morphologically closer to Chinchilloidea with which they have potential phylogenetic affinities. Elasmodontomys remains a problematic taxon as it exhibits inner ear features that are consistent with either Chinchilloidea or Octodontoidea, depending on how the allometric component is evaluated.