Insights into the selectivity of metallic oxides for arsenic and phosphate from EXAFS and DFT calculations

Phosphate is the biggest competitor for arsenic removal. Nanoscale metal oxides (NMOs) are commonly used to treat arsenic-contaminated water, yet their selective adsorption mechanisms for arsenic and phosphate are poorly understood. We quantified the selectivity of iron oxide (Fe2O3), zinc oxide (ZnO), and titanium dioxide (TiO2) nanosheets for arsenic in systems containing arsenic and phosphate, and determined the interaction of phosphate and arsenate/arsenite on metal oxide surfaces through batch experiments, spectroscopic techniques, and DFT calculations. We found that Fe2O3, TiO2, and ZnO nanosheets exhibit selectivity for arsenate/arsenite in the presence of phosphate, with Fe2O3 the most selective, followed by TiO2 and ZnO. The bonding mechanism on these metallic oxide surfaces dominates the selectivity. The more stable inner-sphere complexes of arsenate on the surfaces of Fe2O3 (bidentate binuclear), TiO2 (bidentate binuclear), and ZnO nanosheets (tridentate trinuclear) contribute to their preference for arsenate over phosphate. This difference in arsenate selectivity can be reflected in the difference in adsorption energy, net electron transfer number, and M − O bond length of the most stable inner sphere complexes. Overall, our study elucidated the selective adsorption mechanisms of arsenate/arsenite on Fe2O3, TiO2, and ZnO surfaces and highlighted the need to consider the competition between arsenate and phosphate during their removal from contaminated water.