Reductive chemistry of pyrrolic macrocycles: A PCET dichotomy between metal and ligand

Proton-coupled electron transfer (PCET) is central to the reactivity of porphyrins. The coupling of the electron to the proton is central to a porphyrin's ability to catalyze energy conversion reactions of which the hydrogen evolution reaction (HER) is exemplary. To understand the mechanistic details of the PCET chemistry of porphyrins and related macrocyclic congeners, we have designed hangman constructs that allow a proton, placed in the secondary coordination sphere (off of the hangman backbone), to be coupled to redox transformations at the macrocycle. For metals whose reduction potentials are positive of the porphyrin macrocycle, such as Co and Fe, HER catalysis is confined to PCET transformations of the metal center where the active catalyst for HER is a reduced metal hydride. Alternatively, the reduction potentials of Ni, Zn, and 2H (freebase) porphyrins allow for redox non-innocence of the macrocycle; here the active "hydridic" catalyst is a phlorin, which gives rise to elaborate HER reaction sequences. Beyond HER catalysis, redox non-innocence of Ni, Zn, and 2H porphyrins and related compounds has been informative for providing detailed mechanistic insight into the multi-site PCET hydrogenation of olefinic bonds of the macrocycle. This mini-review unravels the PCET dichotomy between the metal and macrocycle in promoting HER catalysis and novel chemical transformations that give rise to unusual macrocyclic structures.