New insights into the role of AGNs in forming the cluster red sequence

As a considerable investment of time from various telescope facilities were dedicated toward studying the Spiderweb protocluster at z=2.2, it so far remains one of the most extensively studied protocluster. We report here the latest results in this field, adding a new dimension to previous research on cluster formation at high redshift. Previous studies have reported a significant overdensity (delta similar to 10) of massive H alpha (+ [Nii]) -emitting galaxies in 3700 comoving Mpc(3). Many of these were previously considered to be dusty, actively star-forming galaxies, given their rest-frame optical and infrared features. However, this study argues that a third of them are more likely to be "passively-evolving" galaxies with low-luminosity active galactic nuclei (AGNs) rather than star-forming galaxies, given the multi-wavelength spectral energy distribution (SED) fitting including an AGN component. For their SED-based star formation rates to be valid, bulk of their H alpha + [Nii] emission should come from the central AGNs. This difference in interpretation between this work and past studies, including ours, is particularly supported by the recent deep Chandra X-ray observation. Furthermore, we have spectroscopically confirmed a quiescent nature for one of these AGNs, with its multiple stellar absorption lines but also low ionisation emission lines. This important update provides new insights into the role of AGNs in forming the cluster red sequence observed in the present-day universe.