Evaluation of integrated crop management, organic management and natural farming in basmati rice-wheat system under Upper Indo-Gangetic Plains

Field experimentation was conducted to evaluate the comparative performance of integrated crop management, organic management and natural farming on crop growth, productivity, profitability and soil health under basmati rice-wheat system in Upper Indo-Gangetic Plains. Treatments comprised of different management practices viz. integrated crop management (ICM), organic management, natural farming (NF) and control (no nutrient) were used in experimentation. Plant height, number of effective tillers, SPAD meter reading, panicle weight, filled grains/panicle, fertility percentage and 1000-grains weight of basmati rice and wheat were observed highest under ICM followed by organic management. A significant reduction in growth and yield attributes was recorded under NF as compared to ICM and organic management. Grain yield of basmati rice was reduced by 15.2%, 51.2% and 53.9% under organic management, NF and control as compared to ICM, respectively. Similarly, 49.5%, 58.6%, and 63.8% reduction in grain yield of wheat was recorded under organic management, NF and control as compared to ICM, respectively. In comparison to ICM, system rice equivalent yield (REY) was reduced by 32.6%, 55.0%, and 59.0% under organic management, NF and control, respectively. Further, net return was 44.1% and 67.2% lower under organic management and NF as compared to ICM, respectively. Highest soil organic carbon (0.60%), available N, P, and K were found in organic management. Significantly highest soil microbial population, glomalin content and different soil enzyme activities were recorded under organic management. Overall, the integrated crop management provided balanced and continuous supply of the nutrient that resulted in higher productivity and profitability of basmati rice-wheat system.