The different responses of trace elements to equilibrium and disequilibrium melting: Implications for crustal differentiation and granite compositions

Equilibrium and disequilibrium meltings are two common mechanisms in the geochemical differentiation of the continental crust. However, responses of trace elements to the two melting processes are still not fully understood in granite petrogenesis. To address this, we conducted trace element modelling of open system melting using phase equilibrium calculations combined with solubility equations for accessory minerals and mineral-melt partition coefficients based on three melt-reintegrated felsic granulite compositions. The results indicate systematic differences between the compositions of disequilibrium (Type I) and equilibrium (Type II) melts involving water-present melting reaction, fluid-absent melting reaction involving biotite, and fluid-absent melting reaction in the absence of biotite. Type I melts generally have higher Rb, Ba, Co, Ni, V, and Cr contents, and Rb/Sr and Nb/Ta ratios, and lower Sr, P, Th, U, and light rare earth element contents than Type II melts. Significantly, disequilibrium melting involving biotite can produce melts with high Nb contents and superchondritic Nb/Ta ratios, which may be a reservoir for the missing Nb on Earth. Compared with Type II melts, the trace element contents and ratios of Type I melts exhibit a larger range, more complex trends, and are more sensitive to changes in melting reaction types and melt loss. This suggests that, in addition to petrogenetic processes such as crystal entrainment, fractional crystallization and magma mixing, the disequilibrium melting would also contribute to the compositional diversity of granites. The modelling results also show that the trace element signatures of granites that are commonly used to determine their petrogenetic processes and tectonic setting may lead to erroneous conclusions if the granitic melts were produced by disequilibrium melting.