Atypical Endometriosis: Comprehensive Characterization of Clinicopathologic, Immunohistochemical, and Molecular Features

Atypical endometriosis (A-EMS), defined by cytologic atypia and/or crowded glands resembling endometrial intraepithelial neoplasia, remains poorly understood. We aimed to refine the morphologic, immunohistochemical, and molecular features of A-EMS in an institutional series. Cases were identified through a structured search and reviewed by 2 pathologists. Immunohistochemistry and comprehensive sequencing using a panel 447-gene coverage were performed in suitable cases. A-EMS with synchronous and/or subsequent EMS-related neoplasia were compared with those without. Of 4598 EMS cases over an 11-yr period, 36 A-EMS were identified. The mean age at presentation was 46 (range 26-68) yr. Locations included the ovary (24, 66%), tubo-ovary (6, 17%), fallopian tube (3, 8%), and peritoneum (3, 8%). The mean size was 6.5 (range 0.5-40) mm. Cytologic atypia was mild in 4 (11%), moderate in 21 (58%), and severe in 11 (31%). Most lesions were partially or completely flat (28, 78%); of these, 66% showed hobnail nuclei. Crowded/cribriform and micropapillary/papillary patterns were seen in 11 (31%) and 16 (44%) A-EMS, respectively. Immunohistochemistry, performed in 33 A-EMS, showed wildtype p53 (100%) retained PMS2/MSH6 (100%), and positive estrogen receptor (97%, mean 65% cells), progesterone receptor (76%, mean 30% cells), and Napsin A (39%). Ki67 labelling was <1% to 10% (median 5%). Nine (25%) patients presented with concurrent or subsequent ipsilateral endometrioid, seromucinous, or clear cell neoplasia (4 borderline tumors and 4 carcinomas). The only A-EMS feature statistically more frequent in this subset was crowded/glands (6/9 vs. 2/27 A-EMS without, P=0.001 Fisher exact test). Sequencing showed pathogenic variants in 5 of 6 cases analyzed, involving ATM, BRCA2, KRAS, AKT, CTNNB1, PTEN, and ARID1A among other genes. In 2 cases, synchronous neoplasia showed an accumulation of additional variants. A-EMS is characterized by cytologic atypia and crowded architecture but low proliferation index, positive estrogen receptor, and normal p53 and MMR, which can be helpful in the distinction from malignancy. The prevalence of synchronous/subsequent tubo-ovarian neoplasia in our series was 25%, significantly higher than the reported 1% in conventional EMS. Moreover, A-EMS harbors genomic alterations seen in EMS-related tumors and shares pathogenic variants with synchronous ipsilateral neoplasia. Therefore, it is important to report A-EMS as currently defined and describe its architectural features, especially gland crowding as this appears to increase the risk of EMS-related epithelial neoplasia. Napsin-A is often positive in A-EMS and should be interpreted with caution.