Cushioning Effect of Conventional Padded Helmets on Interaction between Cerebrospinal Fluid and Brain after a Low-Speed Head Impact

Results of a recent experimental study challenge the widely-held belief that modern combat helmets are more effective at protecting soldiers against concussions. The research shows that helmets used during First World War without inner paddings may have an advantage in protecting soldiers’ brains from concussions when relying solely on cerebrospinal fluid. The present study explains this counterintuitive finding by revealing that while cerebrospinal fluid can prevent direct brain-to-skull contact during a single event, its protective capabilities diminish with each subsequent event occurring in quick succession—something conventional padded helmets appear to aggravate. The cerebrospinal fluid requires a certain amount of time to reset after an acceleration/deceleration event, which allows it to effectively provide cushioning for any subsequent events and protect against potential brain damage. However, an immediate occurrence of a subsequent event, when the fluid has no time to settle down, may significantly diminish the effectiveness of the fluid’s ability to provide adequate cushioning, thereby putting individuals at risk of serious injury. This new information may have implications for helmet design in the future and calls into question current assumptions regarding the best way to protect soldiers and athletes from concussions.