Transitional cluster dynamics in a model for delay-coupled chemical oscillators (vol 33, 063133, 2023)

Cluster synchronization is a fundamental phenomenon in systems of coupled oscillators. Here, we investigate clustering patterns that emerge during experiments with delay-coupled electrochemical oscillators. A voltage parameter in the experimental set-up controls the onset of oscillations via a Hopf bifurcation. For a smaller voltage, the oscillators exhibit simple, so-called primary, clustering patterns, where all phase differences between each set of coupled oscillators are identical. However, upon increasing the voltage, more interesting secondary states, where phase differences differ, are detected, in addition to the primary states. Previous work on this system saw the development of a mathematical model that explained how the existence, stability, and common frequency of the experimentally observed cluster states could be accurately controlled by the delay time of the coupling. In this study, we revisit the mathematical model of the electrochemical oscillators in order to address open questions by means of bifurcation analysis. Our analysis reveals how the stable cluster states, corresponding to experimental observations, lose their stability via an assortment of bifurcation types. The analysis further reveals a complex interconnectedness between branches of different cluster types; in particular, we find that each secondary state provides a continuous transition between certain primary states. These connections are explained by studying the phase space and parameter symmetries of the respective states. Furthermore, we show that it is only for a larger value of the voltage parameter that the branches of secondary states develop intervals of stability. Otherwise, for a smaller voltage, all the branches of secondary states are completely unstable and therefore hidden to experimentalists.