Discussion about “estimation of curie depth, geothermal gradient and near-surface heat flow from spectral analysis of aeromagnetic data in the loum-minta area (centre-east cameroon)”

Background: this paper reviews the results obtained from recent studies mentioning the crustal architecture in Cameroon. It also discusses the study of [1] “Estimation of Curie depth, geothermal gradient and near-surface heat flow from spectral analysis of aeromagnetic data in the Loum-Minta area (Centre-East Cameroon)”. The paper published by [1] is an application of the spectral method for the determination of Curie depths, followed by interpretations on the local thermal structure (thermal gradient, heat flux) of the crust. However, some outliers are remarkable and depend at first analysis on a bad mesh of the data following a windows of 27.75 * 27.75 km. Similarly, the failure to take into account the various parameters (seismic, geological, tectonic) which would help to better calibrate the results. Discussion: with this communication, we would like to mention and clarify some errors in the paper published by [1] based on a global review of thermal behaviour of the crust. Summary: It is strongly recommended that information on regional geology and seismicity be used to estimate the Curie depths and that other independent data be integrated to determine the thermal and mechanical behaviour of the crust in Cameroon.