The initial phase of the Hönne Valley Reef at Binolen (northern Rhenish Massif, Middle Devonian)

The Hagen-Balve Reef Complex of the northern Rhenish Massif, Germany, is one of the best examples for the globally widespread Givetian to Frasnian reefs. At its eastern end, in the Hönne Valley, it reaches up to 1000 metres in thickness. In general, there is limited knowledge concerning the faunas and palaeoecology of Rhenish initial reef phases. A unique section at Binolen exposes the sharp boundary between the underlying, siliciclastic Upper Honsel Formation and the lower part of the reefal Hagen-Balve Formation. A ca. 14 m thick succession is assigned to the new Binolen Member and investigated in terms of carbonate microfacies, micro-, and macrofaunas. Seven microfacies types ( MF ) characterise a crinoidal coral-stromatoporoid garden setting ( MF-2 to MF-6 ) or allobiostrome of an initial open platform turning upsection into a coral parabiostrome ( MF-7/8 ). The base of the Asbeck Member is locally defined by the appearance of back-reef facies types, such as fenestral limestones ( MF-9 ), which indicate the transformation into a bioherm. Low-diversity conodont faunas prove an influx of open shelf organisms for the Binolen Member and suggest a lower Givetian age (probably Polygnathus timorensis Zone). There are two new Givetian conodont biofacies types characteristic for open biostrome settings, the Bipennatus Biofacies and a Simple Cone Biofacies. Thin sections reveal over 40 different reef builders (rugose and tabulate corals, stromatoporoids, and chaetetid sponges). Around 4200 microfossils from conodont residues consist of agglutinating foraminifers, calcareous sponge spicules (e.g. Heteractinida), scolecodonts, echinoderms (mostly crinoid ossicles and holothurian sclerites), pyritised benthic ostracods, assumed calcified moulds of chitinozoans, subordinate microvertebrates, and other groups. They were analysed quantitatively in order to document changing distribution patterns and environments through time. We distinguish six microfossil-based biofacies types ( BF ), namely the Ostracoda Biofacies ( BF-O ), Foraminifera Biofacies ( BF-F ), Scolecodont Biofacies ( BF-S ), Chitinozoa Biofacies ( BF-C ), Porifera-Scolecodont Biofacies ( BF-PS ), and Porifera-Echinodermata Biofacies ( BF-PE ). Microfacies and microfossil assemblages led to a reconstruction of the local facies development, consisting of seven successive depophases with further subdivisions. At the base, the sudden termination of siliciclastic influx enabled a proliferation of reef builders and microfaunas (Depophase I), followed by a longer deepening phase characterised by exclusive bioclastic wackestones (Depophase II). Depophase III is a short regressive phase with crinoidal coral-stromatoporoid floatstones. Depophase IV is characterised by fluctuations in facies and relative sea-level, which results in three subphases. Depophase V resembles Depophase III, but with argillaceous interbeds and more abundant scolecodonts. It is followed by an interval with coral-stromatoporoid rudstones, which grade into coral-dominated bafflestones of an (auto)parabiostrome (both Depophase VI). Depophase VII represent the back-reef facies, including fenestral pack-bindstones of the basal Asbeck Member. The systematic analysis of reefal microfaunas represents pioneer work that should be tested and expanded to other reefs of the Rhenish Massif and beyond.