Mercurial possibilities: determining site distributions in Cu2HgSnS4 using Cu-63/65, Sn-119, and Hg-199 solid-state NMR spectroscopy

Chalcogenides are an important class of materials that exhibit tailorable optoelectronic properties accessible through chemical modification. For example, the minerals kesterite, stannite, and velikite (Cu2MSnS4, where M = Zn, Cd, or Hg, respectively) are a series of Group 12 transition metal tin sulfides that readily exhibit optical bandgaps spanning the Shockley-Queisser limit; however, achieving consensus on their structure (space group I4 vs. I42m) has been difficult. This study explores the average long-range and local structure of Cu2HgSnS4 and evaluates the parallels of M = Zn and Cd sister compounds using complementary X-ray diffraction and solid-state nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy. The Cu-63/65 NMR spectra were acquired at multiple magnetic field strengths (B-0 = 7.05, 11.75, and 21.1 T) to assess the unique chemical shift anisotropy and quadrupolar coupling contributions. They reveal two inequivalent sets of Cu sites in Cu2ZnSnS4, in contrast to only one set of sites in Cu2CdSnS4 and Cu2HgSnS4, clarifying structural assignments previously proposed through X-ray diffraction methods. The presence of these Cu sites was further supported by DFT calculations. The Sn-119 and Hg-199 NMR spectra suggest that an ordering phenomenon takes place in Cu2HgSnS4 when it undergoes annealing treatments. The trend in measured optical band gaps (1.5 eV for Cu2ZnSnS4, 1.2 eV for Cu2CdSnS4, and 0.9 eV for Cu2HgSnS4) was confirmed by electronic structure calculations, which show that the band gap narrows as the difference in electronegativity is diminished and that Hg-S bonds in Cu2HgSnS4 have greater covalent character.