Students’ perception and learning experience in the first medical clerkship

Background The German clerkship (“Famulatur”) is the first phase in medical education, in which students learn from a physician’s perspective. According to the German Licensing Regulations for Physicians, students shall “familiarise” with providing care. However, specific learning objectives for the clerkship are not defined, although the acquisition of different competencies is implicitly demanded. Therefore, an additional understanding of the clerkship students’ learning experience is needed. The goal of this study is to explore the student’s learning perspective and experiences in the clerkship. Methods Twelve guideline-based interviews were conducted with third year medical students. All participants completed their first clerkship. A qualitative content analysis was performed. The inductively identified categories were transferred into a quantitative questionnaire using a 5-point Likert-scale to explore their relevance in a validation cohort. The questionnaire was completed by 222 clinical students of the Otto-von-Guericke-Universität Magdeburg. Results The qualitative analysis led to 26 individual items assigned to 4 main categories that describe the clerkship experience: 1) “coping with insecurities”, 2) “the clerkship as a social arrangement”, 3) “the clerkship as a learning opportunity” and 4) “the clerkship as a teaching opportunity”. In the quantitative validation cohort, category one yielded a well-balanced result (median 3 = “neither agree nor disagree”; IQR 2–4), items addressed in categories 2–4 were generally supported by the students, predominantly selecting “strongly agree” or “agree” (Median 2; IQR 1–2 for each category). Students rated the role of the clinical team as especially important for their learning success and feared exclusion or negative reactions. Conclusions The medical clerkship provides an institutional, professional, and social framework, in which students are learning. Insecurities arose from curricular inconsistencies, a high dependency on the clinical team as well as the absence of specific learning objectives. Therefore, a better curricular integration regarding the semester structure and the learning objectives of the German clerkship is needed.