MISTAKE-MAKING: A THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK FOR GENERATING RESEARCH QUESTIONS IN BIOLOGY, WITH ILLUSTRATIVE APPLICATION TO BLOOD CLOTTING

It is a matter of contention whether or not a general explanatory framework for the biological sciences would be of scientific value, or whether it is even achievable. In this paper we suggest that both are the case, and we outline proposals for a framework capable of generating new scientific questions. Starting with one clear characteristic of biological systems-that they all have the potential to make mistakes-we aim to describe the nature of this potential and the common processes that lie behind it. Given that under most circumstances biological systems function effectively, an examination of different kinds of mistake-making provides pointers to mechanisms that must exist to make failure uncommon. This, in turn, informs a framework for systematic inquiry, which in this paper we apply to the hemostatic system, but we believe could be applied to any system across biology.