The Impact of Multiple Pond Conditions on the Performance of Dike-Pond Extraction

Dike-ponds in fisheries often present multiple pond conditions such as pure, suspended sediment, water bloom, semidry conditions, etc. However, the impact of these conditions on the performance of extracting dike-pond from remote sensing images has not been studied. To solve this problem, we explore the existence of such impacts by comparing the performance of four rule-based methods in two groups of test regions. The first group has few multiple pond conditions, while the second has more. The results show that various measure values deteriorate as the proportion of multiple pond conditions in the regions increases. All four methods performed worse in the second group than the first, where the overall accuracy decreased by 8.80%, misclassification error increased by 3.69%, omission error raised by 10.53%, and correct quantity rate dropped by 8.23%, respectively. The extraction method that ingested multiple pond conditions performed indistinguishably from the other methods in the first group. However, it outperformed the other methods in the second group, with a 4.22% improvement in overall accuracy, a 10.25% decrease in misclassification error, and a 19.03% increase in the correct quantity rate. These findings suggest that multiple pond conditions can negatively impact the extraction performance and should be considered in dike-pond applications that require a precise pond size, number, and shape.