Molecular phylogenetics of Euploca (Boraginaceae): homoplasy in many characters, including the C-4 photosynthetic pathway

We present a phylogenetic analysis using plastid (matK, rbcL) and nuclear (nrITS) DNA for diverse Euploca spp. (formerly Heliotropium section Orthostachys) from the worldwide distribution of a genus and including species encompassing the wide physiological and morphological diversity of the genus. Our results indicate that some remarkably complex features arose multiple times in parallel in Euploca, including attributes of its subsections under section Orthostachys, notably plants that, above ground, consist almost entirely of inflorescences. To elucidate in greater detail the distribution of C-4 species in Euploca and Heliotropium s.s., we made > 800 delta C-13 determinations, including some from the traditional genus Tournefortia. We greatly increase the number of proven C-4 species in Euploca, but found none outside Euploca. Of the tested Euploca spp., c. 28% are C-3 or intermediate in carbon fixation pathway. Our phylogenetic results indicate four parallel/convergent acquisitions of C-4 photosynthesis or fewer origins with subsequent loss in some species.