Economics of reducing antibiotic usage for pathogen-specific clinical mastitis through genomic selection and disease management

The recent introduction of the mastitis resistance trait into the US genomic selection index, Lifetime Net Merit 2018 (NM$), is expected to reduce the incidence of pathogen-specific clinical mastitis (PS-CM) incidence in U.S. dairy herds. To maximize the herd performance by reducing the PS-CM incidence, we compared the herd performance of 6 different replacement selection and PS-CM disease management strategies. We used an agent-based dairy simulation model in which the performance of individual animals was affected by the genetic traits included in the NM$. The genetic trends for the sires used affected the 15 yr herd performance. Each animal had a daily underlying base probability of contracting 5 different types of PS-CM (Staphylococcus aureus, Streptococcus dysgalactiae, Strep. uberis, Escherichia coli and Klebsiella) during lactation. On top of this base probability, the genetic and environmental components of the mastitis resistance trait (MAST) determined the actual incidence of PS-CM. Genomic estimated breeding values were simulated for each animal, based on which replacement selection decisions were made. The PS-CM associated milk loss, increased somatic cell count, decreased conception, and increased mortality and culling were accounted for in the simulated genomic estimated breeding values of different correlated production and reproduction traits included in NM$. The 6 different strategies illustrate the effects of replacement selection and PS-CM management decisions on PS-CM incidence, herd antibiotic use (ABU) and herd economics, over the course of 15 yr. Due to the genetic gain in the MAST, the incidence of PS-CM decreased on average by 10% points in 15 yr, which trickled down to overall reduction in herd ABU. Our PS-CM treatment and prevention strategies were assumed to be based on precise information about the 5 different PS-CM causative pathogens. Hence the corresponding ABU further decreased over the course of 15 years, when compared to blanket PS-CM therapies, which used antibiotics for all cases of CM. Our strategies illustrated the fact that herds combining genomic selection and following precise treatment and prevention strategies for PS-CM could reduce the 15-year cumulative ABU against PS-CM significantly. Capitalizing on the genetic gain in NM$ traits, the average profit per cow per year was higher on average by $1209 in year 15 when compared to year 0 for the 6 strategies simulated. We concluded that three decision strategies (genomic selection for NM$, selective therapy for PS-CM, and selective dry cow therapy for PS-CM prevention) when combined can reduce the incidence of PS-CM and the associated ABU, while increasing the profitability of the herd.