Dural substitutes for spina bifida repair: past, present, and future

Purpose The use of materials to facilitate dural closure during spina bifida (SB) repair has been a highly studied aspect of the surgical procedure. The overall objective of this review is to present key findings pertaining to the success of the materials used in clinical and pre-clinical studies. Additionally, this review aims to aid fetal surgeons as they prepare for open or fetoscopic prenatal SB repairs. Methods Relevant publications centered on dural substitutes used during SB repair were identified. Important information from each article was extracted including year of publication, material class and sub-class, animal model used in pre-clinical studies, whether the repair was conducted pre-or postnatally, the bioactive agent delivered, and key findings from the study. Results Out of 1,121 publications, 71 were selected for full review. We identified the investigation of 33 different patches where 20 and 63 publications studied synthetic and natural materials, respectively. From this library, 43.6% focused on clinical results, 36.6% focused on pre-clinical results, and 19.8% focused on tissue engineering approaches. Overall, the use of patches, irrespective of material, have shown to successfully protect the spinal cord and most have shown promising survival and neurological outcomes. Conclusion While most have shown significant promise as a therapeutic strategy in both clinical and pre-clinical studies, none of the patches developed so far are deemed perfect for SB repair. Therefore, there is an opportunity to develop new materials and strategies that aim to overcome these challenges and further improve the outcomes of SB patients.