Evaluating Alignment of Shapes by Ensemble Visualization

The visualization of variability in surfaces embedded in 3D, which is a type of ensemble uncertainty visualization, provides a means of understanding the underlying distribution of a collection or ensemble of surfaces. Although ensemble visualization for isosurfaces has been described in the literature, we conduct an expert-based evaluation of various ensemble visualization techniques in a particular medical imaging application: the construction of atlases or templates from a population of images. In this work, we extend contour boxplot to 3D, allowing us to evaluate it against an enumeration-style visualization of the ensemble members and other conventional visualizations used by atlas builders, namely examining the atlas image and the corresponding images/data provided as part of the construction process. We present feedback from domain experts on the efficacy of contour boxplot compared to other modalities when used as part of the atlas construction and analysis stages of their work.