Tropical TGF Paradox: A Perspective from TRMM Precipitation Radar

The Terrestrial Gamma-ray Flash (TGF) to lightning ratio, computed over the three tropical chimneys, presents a paradox: African thunderstorms produce the most lightning but yield the lowest fraction of TGFs when compared to American and Southeast Asian thunderstorms. To understand the physical insights into this asymmetry, Tropical Rainfall Measuring Mission Precipitation Radar measurements are used to depict the vertical precipitation structure and infer the vertical electrical charge fraction distribution of the observed thunderstorms in the three regions and the thunderstorms during TGF occurrences detected by the AGILE, Fermi-GBM, and RHESSI sensors. Regional differences show that African thunderstorms are taller, smaller, and have a higher concentration of denser ice particles (graupel and or hail) above the freezing level in addition to having more lightning flashes per thunderstorm. The overall TGF-related thunderstorms are taller, more intense (0.5-1.5 dBZ) and present similar radar reflectivity decay with height independent of the region. The two dimensional precipitation vertical distribution diagrams indicate that TGF thunderstorms develop to a mature stage. Independent of the region, thunderstorms show a midlevel negative charge center varying from 4.6 to 8.1 km in height and an upper level positive charge center ranging from 7.4 to 14.6 km. TGF thunderstorms have thicker positive inferred charge layer and present larger vertical distances between the opposite charging layers in comparison with the overall thunderstorm population, here defined as Climatology. African TGF thunderstorms have higher fraction of positive charges near the negative layer, helping to produce more and shorter lightning discharges.