A plan evaluation framework for examining stakeholder policy preferences in resilience planning and management of urban systems

•A quantitative approach to examine policy preference conflicts among diverse stakeholders across multiple plans.•Hazard mitigation plan incorporated the most overall stakeholder policy preferences among the four examined plans.•The regional transportation plan incorporated the fewest overall stakeholder policy preferences.•The hazard mitigation plan and the regional conservation plan had the highest level of policy consistency.•The hazard mitigation plan and regional transportation plan had the lowest level of policy consistency.