Micro RNAs Are Minor Constituents of Extracellular Vesicles and Are Hardly Delivered to Target Cells

Mammalian cells release different types of vesicles, collectively termed extracellular vesicles (EVs). EVs contain cellular and viral microRNAs (miRNAs) with an apparent potential to deliver their miRNA cargo to recipient cells to affect the stability of individual mRNAs and the transcriptome. The extent to which miRNAs are exported via the EV route and whether they contribute to cell-cell communication are controversial. To address these issues, we analyzed the capacity of EVs to deliver packaged miRNAs into target cells and to exert biological functions. We applied well-defined approaches to produce and characterize purified EVs with or without specific viral miRNAs. Only a small fraction of EVs carried miRNAs. EVs bound to different target cell types, but there was no EV-cell membrane fusion or delivery of cargo. Importantly, the functionality of cells exposed to miRNA-carrying EVs was not affected. These results suggest EV-borne miRNAs do not act as effectors and question their relevancy in paracrine cell-to-cell communication. AUTHOR SUMMARY The majority of metazoan cells release vesicles of different types and origins, such as exosomes and microvesicles, now collectively termed extracellular vesicles (EVs). EVs have gained much attention because they contain microRNAs (miRNAs) and thus regulate their specific mRNA targets in recipient or acceptor cells that take up EVs. Using a novel fusion assay with superior sensitivity and specificity, we revisited this claim but found no convincing evidence for an efficient functional uptake of EVs in cell lines and primary human blood cells. Even EVs engineered to fuse and deliver their miRNA cargo to recipient cells had no measurable effect on target mRNAs in very carefully controlled, quantitative experiments. Our negative results clearly indicate that EVs do not act as vehicles for miRNA-based cell-to-cell communication.