Multiple Mechanisms of HIV-1 resistance to PGT135 in Chinese Subtype B' Slow Progressor

ABSTRACT In our study, we describe a slow progressor CBJC515 from whom we constructed pseudoviruses expressing autologous Env. We surprisingly found all the pseudoviruses were resistant to PGT135. By making site-directed mutations and chimeric Env constructs, we found the early 05 strains escaped from PGT135 by losing the N332 glycan site, while the later 06 and 08 strains may escape with the retention of key epitopes through the change of V1/V4/C2 region or by N398/N611 glycan, which was selected as unique N-glycosylation site of CBJC515 compared with CBJC437 whose viruses were also harboring key epitopes but sensitive to PGT135. These findings provide insights into how HIV-1 can escape from N332-directed broadly neutralizing antibody (bNAb) responses without changing the epitope itself, and these ways may be useful to prolong the exposures of bNAb epitopes and contribute to bNAb development. Furthermore, our chimeric experiments also allowed us to explore the co-evolution and retention of functionality among regions. We confirmed that the V1V2 region has a wide range of effectiveness in interfering with the function of envelope protein and the V3 region can promote protein function recovery and buffer the harmful polymorphisms in the other regions contributing to the Env antigenic diversity. These results may provide some clues for the design of vaccines against HIV-1 strains. IMPORTANCE Our findings of mechanisms escaping from PGT135 verified the extensive role of long V1 region in mediating escape from V3-bNAbs. In addition, we also found multiple additional ways suggested that extreme variation may be needed by HIV-1 to escape from PGT135 without changing the epitope itself. Although the V3-glycan bNAb responses are among the most promising vaccine targets, as they are commonly elicited during infection, our findings indicated there may be additional difficulties to be taken into account in immunogen design, such as the consideration of other regions and some glycosylation sites affecting the mask of key epitopes, as well as the selection pressure that may be required by other bNAbs. Our chimeric experiment also highlighted the key role of V3 region in contributing to the maintenance of Env diversity by buffering deleterious polymorphisms, which may be helpful for vaccine design.