Phenotypic Plasticity of the Thermal Reaction Norms for Development in the Multicolored Asian Lady Beetle, Harmonia axyridis (Pallas) (Coleoptera, Coccinellidae)

Phenotypic plasticity of insect thermal reaction norms (TRNs) (the lower thermal threshold, coefficient of thermal sensitivity, and sum of degree-days) ensures precise adjustment of the seasonal cycle to local environments by changing the pattern of temperature-dependence of developmental rate. In different geographic populations the plasticity of TRNs can be manifested in different ways. We investigated the photoperiodic and diet-induced plasticity of TRNs, body mass and structural size (hind femur length) of the multicolored Asian ladybird, Harmonia axyridis , from native (Irkutsk) and invasive (Sochi) laboratory populations. Each population was tested in 16 experimental treatments that represented combinations of 4 temperatures (17, 20, 24, and 28°C), 2 photoperiods (10 and 16 h of light per day), and 2 larval diets (frozen eggs of the grain moth Sitotroga cerealella and larvae and adults of the green peach aphid Myzus persicae ). The lady beetle eggs developed at a temperature of 20°C; first instar larvae were distributed among experimental treatments. We have demonstrated that under both photoperiodic regimes larval feeding on a low-quality diet (grain moth eggs) resulted in a disproportional (more strongly manifested at a low temperature) retardation of preimaginal development of individuals from both populations. The lower temperature thresholds for preimaginal development were also greater on the inferior diet. When fed on grain moth eggs, larvae from the Irkutsk population showed weaker temperature-sensitivity of development, whereas in the Sochi population the slope of the TRN did not differ between the two diets. In contrast, H. axyridis from Irkutsk showed practically no photoperiodic plasticity of TRN, whereas those from Sochi were sensitive to photoperiod on both diets. Under short-day conditions, the lower temperature threshold in the latter population was smaller and temperature-sensitivity was weaker so that at the temperatures of 17 and 20°C, development under short-day conditions was faster than that under long-day conditions, whereas at 28°C, on the contrary, it was slightly slower. In both studied populations the thermal plasticity of adult body mass and hind femur length was manifested in different ways and to varying degrees, depending on the larval photoperiodic conditions and diet. Adult body mass could decrease or increase with larval developmental temperature or show no change. Despite being maintained in the laboratory for many generations, the H. axyridis populations from Sochi and Irkutsk have retained differences in physiological responses to photoperiodic conditions and larval diet.