Leveraging The Value Of Cdisc Send Data Sets For Cross-Study Analysis: Incidence Of Microscopic Findings In Control Animals

Implementation of the Clinical Data Interchange Standards Consortium (CDISC)'s Standard for Exchange of Nonclinical Data (SEND) by the United States Food and Drug Administration Center for Drug Evaluation and Research (US FDA CDER) has created large quantities of SEND data sets and a tremendous opportunity to apply large-scale data analytic approaches. To fully realize this opportunity, differences in SEND implementation that impair the ability to conduct cross-study analysis must be addressed. In this manuscript, a prototypical question regarding historical control data (see Table of Contents graphic) was used to identify areas for SEND harmonization and to develop algorithmic strategies for nonclinical cross-study analysis within a variety of databases. FDA CDER's repository of >1800 sponsor-submitted studies in SEND format was queried using the statistical programming language R to gain insight into how the CDISC SEND Implementation Guides are being applied across the industry. For each component needed to answer the question (defined as "query block"), the frequency of data population was determined and ranged from 6 to 99%. For fields populated <90% and/or that did not have Controlled Terminology, data extraction methods such as data transformation and script development were evaluated. Data extraction was successful for fields such as phase of study, negative controls, and histopathology using scripts. Calculations to assess accuracy of data extraction indicated a high confidence in most query block searches. Some fields such as vehicle name, animal supplier name, and test facility name are not amenable to accurate data extraction through script development alone and require additional harmonization to confidently extract data. Harmonization proposals are discussed in this manuscript. Implementation of these proposals will allow stakeholders to capitalize on the opportunity presented by SEND data sets to increase the efficiency and productivity of nonclinical drug development, allowing the most promising drug candidates to proceed through development.