Economic Interpretation of Demand Curves in Multi-Product Electricity Markets − Part II: Practice

Following Part I of this paper that reveals two distinct interpretations of demand curves and the corresponding different forms of the market clearing formulation, Part II of this paper analyzes the sequential and the iterative market clearing algorithms currently implemented in some markets. It is shown that these algorithms lead to socially sub-optimal solutions. The root cause of the problem is the lack of a clear representation of the demand benefit. The social surplus optimization based on the proper interpretation of demand curves is then proposed. A small numerical example is used to demonstrate the significant optimality gap between the socially optimal solution and the sequential/iterative solution. The potentially large impacts of the gap on the societal benefit and the individual resource revenues entail a close examination of these algorithms.