Comparison of complex modeling strategies for prediction of a binary outcome based on a few, highly correlated predictors.
BIOMETRICAL JOURNAL(2020)
Abstract
Motivated by a clinical prediction problem, a simulation study was performed to compare different approaches for building risk prediction models. Robust prediction models for hospital survival in patients with acute heart failure were to be derived from three highly correlated blood parameters measured up to four times, with predictive ability having explicit priority over interpretability. Methods that relied only on the original predictors were compared with methods using an expanded predictor space including transformations and interactions. Predictors were simulated as transformations and combinations of multivariate normal variables which were fitted to the partly skewed and bimodally distributed original data in such a way that the simulated data mimicked the original covariate structure. Different penalized versions of logistic regression as well as random forests and generalized additive models were investigated using classical logistic regression as a benchmark. Their performance was assessed based on measures of predictive accuracy, model discrimination, and model calibration. Three different scenarios using different subsets of the original data with different numbers of observations and events per variable were investigated. In the investigated setting, where a risk prediction model should be based on a small set of highly correlated and interconnected predictors, Elastic Net and also Ridge logistic regression showed good performance compared to their competitors, while other methods did not lead to substantial improvements or even performed worse than standard logistic regression. Our work demonstrates how simulation studies that mimic relevant features of a specific data set can support the choice of a good modeling strategy.
MoreTranslated text
Key words
correlated predictors,elastic net,random forests,ridge regression,risk prediction models
AI Read Science
Must-Reading Tree
Example
![](https://originalfileserver.aminer.cn/sys/aminer/pubs/mrt_preview.jpeg)
Generate MRT to find the research sequence of this paper
Chat Paper
Summary is being generated by the instructions you defined