MICS-Asia III: Multi-model comparison of reactive Nitrogen deposition over China

Abstract. Atmospheric nitrogen deposition in China has attracted huge public attention in recently years due to the increasing anthropogenic emission of reactive nitrogen (Nr) and its impacts on the terrestrial and aquatic ecosystems. However, limited long-term and multi-site measurements have restrained the understanding on the mechanism of the Nr deposition as well as the chemical transport model (CTM) improvement. In this study, the performance of the simulated wet and dry deposition for different Nr species, i.e., particulate NO3− and NH4+, gaseous NOx, HNO3 and NH3, have been conducted using the framework of Model Inter-Comparison Study for Asia (MICS-Asia) phase III. Nine Models, including 5 WRF-CAMQ models, 2 self-developed regional models, a global model and a RAMS-CMAQ model, have been selected for the comparison. For wet depositions, observation data from 83 measurement sites of EANET, CREN, CAUDN, NADMN and DEE of China have been collected and normalized to compare with model results. In general, most models showed the consistent spatial and temporal variation of both oxidized N (Nox) and reduced N (Nrd) wet depositions in China with the NME around at 50 %, which is lower than the value of 70 % based on EANET observation over Asia. Both the ratio of wet or dry deposition to the total inorganic N deposition (TIN) and the ratios of TIN to their emissions have shown the consistent results with the NNDMN estimations. The performance of ensemble results (ENM) was further assessed with the measurement from satellite. In different regions of China, the results showed that the simulated Nox wet deposition was overestimated in North East China (NE) but underestimated in south of China (SE+SW), while the Nrd wet deposition was underpredicted in all regions by all models. The deposition of Nox have large uncertainties than the Nrd especially in North China (NC), indicating chemical reaction process is one of the most importance factors that affecting the model performance. Compared to Critical load (CL) value, the Nr deposition in NC, SE and SW reached or exceeded the reported CL value and exerted serious ecological impacts. The control of Nrd in NC and SW and Nox in SE would be effective to mitigate the TIN deposition in these regions. More interestingly, the Nr deposition in Tibet plateau with the high ratio of TIN/emission (~3.0), indicating a significant import from outside should be focused in the future due to its climatical influence to the sensitive ecosystem in whole China.