Alternatives to amelogenin markers for sex determination in humans and their forensic relevance

Forensic DNA typing and subsequent molecular methods of sex determination in humans have been proven to be an imperious tool to criminal justice system. In current practice, most of the short tandem repeat (STR) based commercial kits contain amelogenin as the sexing marker. Amelogenin gene which contributes to the tooth enamel formation is present on both X and Y chromosome with a variation in base pair size. However, huge discrepancies have been observed with amelogenin based sex determination mostly due to X and Y deletion in the population and mutation in primer binding sites. Some ethnicities such as those in Indian population are affected badly with inappropriate sex determination by amelogenin marker due to the presence of high frequency of Y deletion in the population. Presence of PCR inhibitors, degradation in the DNA samples and presence of mixed DNA also contribute to the discrepancy in results obtained by amelogenin analysis. To overcome this problem, many alternative markers/techniques such as STS , SRY , TSPY , DXYS156 , SNPs, DYZ1 and Next generation sequencing have been discussed in much detail with their respective pros and cons. In this regard, inclusion of one or more alternative markers along with amelogenin will decrease the anomalies in sex determination observed while using the amelogenin marker alone in forensic sample analysis.