Comparison of salvage therapies for isolated para-aortic lymph node recurrence in patients with uterine cervical cancer after definitive treatment

Background Some studies have demonstrated that concurrent chemo-radiotherapy is an effective salvage treatment for isolated para-aortic lymph node (PALN) recurrence. However, no studies have compared multi-treatment modalities, such as radiation therapy (RT), concurrent chemoradiotherapy (CCRT), surgery, chemotherapy, and best supportive care (BSC), across a sufficient number of patients with PALN recurrence. We thus aimed to evaluate the clinical outcomes of multi-treatment modalities for isolated PALN recurrence in uterine cervical cancer. Methods Records of 50 patients who were first diagnosed with isolated PALN recurrence after definitive cervical cancer treatment from 2002 to 2016 at our institution were reviewed retrospectively. The initial definitive cervical cancer therapies included RT alone, CCRT, or surgery with or without post-operative RT. The median follow-up time was 33 months. The median age at recurrence diagnosis was 57 years (range, 26–84 years). The median duration between the end of initial treatment and recurrence was 10 months (range, 1–91 months). The median maximum metastatic lesion size was 17 mm (range, 8–60 mm). Twenty-four patients had one or two PALN metastases, while 26 had 3 or more. Eighteen patients were treated for recurrence with RT alone, seven with CCRT, three with surgery, 17 with chemotherapy, and five with BSC. Potential prognostic factors included histopathology, initial FIGO stage, initial treatment, age at recurrence, tumor markers (serum SCC-Ag and CEA) at recurrence, time to recurrence, maximum size of the metastatic lesion, number of metastases, and the recurrence treatment method. Results The 3-year overall survival (OS) rates of all patients were 47.0%. The 3-year OS rate of patients who underwent CCRT for recurrence was 85.7%; surgery, 66.7%; chemotherapy, 48.8%; RT, 41.3%; and BSC, 0% ( p = 0.014). Univariate analysis revealed that only the recurrence treatment method was significantly associated with OS. The 3-year local control rate (LCR) and progression free survival (PFS) rate for CCRT were 100 and 71.4%; for surgery, 100 and 66.7%; for chemotherapy, 33.6 and 13.7%; and for RT, 55.5 and 14.1%, respectively (LCR: p = 0.028, PFS: p = 0.059). The number of metastatic lesions, SCC-Ag levels and recurrence treatment method were significantly associated with LCR. Age at recurrence, SCC-Ag levels, and number of metastatic lesions were significantly associated with PFS. Conclusions Although our patient cohort size was small, our results suggest that CCRT may be effective in preventing local disease recurrence in the PALN and may improve OS.