Team of Rivals in a Kagome Material: Quantum Spin Liquid, Spin Order, and Valence Bond Crystal

When the bonds of a quantum magnet are modulated with a periodic pattern, exotic quantum ground states may emerge. Newly synthesized crystalline barlowite (Cu$_4$(OH)$_6$FBr) and Zn-substituted barlowite demonstrate the delicate interplay between singlet states and spin order on the spin-$\frac{1}{2}$ kagome lattice. Our new variant of barlowite maintains hexagonal symmetry at low temperatures with an arrangement of distorted and undistorted kagome triangles, for which numerical simulations predict a pinwheel valence bond crystal (VBC) state instead of a quantum spin liquid (QSL). The presence of interlayer spins eventually leads to novel pinwheel \textit{q=0} magnetic order. Partially Zn-substituted barlowite (Cu$_{3.44}$Zn$_{0.56}$(OH)$_6$FBr) has an ideal kagome lattice and shows QSL behavior, demonstrating the robustness of the QSL against local impurities. This system is a unique playground displaying QSL, VBC, and spin order, furthering our understanding of these highly competitive quantum states.