Crosstalk And Ultrasensitivity In Protein Degradation Pathways

Protein turnover is vital to cellular homeostasis. Many proteins are degraded efficiently only after they have been post-translationally "tagged" with a polyubiquitin chain. Ubiquitylation is a form of Post-Translational Modification (PTM): addition of a ubiquitin to the chain is catalyzed by E3 ligases, and removal of ubiquitin is catalyzed by a De-UBiquitylating enzyme (DUB). Nearly four decades ago, Goldbeter and Koshland discovered that reversible PTM cycles function like on-off switches when the substrates are at saturating concentrations. Although this finding has had profound implications for the understanding of switch-like behavior in biochemical networks, the general behavior of PTM cycles subject to synthesis and degradation has not been studied. Using a mathematical modeling approach, we found that simply introducing protein turnover to a standard modification cycle has profound effects, including significantly reducing the switch-like nature of the response. Our findings suggest that many classic results on PTM cycles may not hold in vivo where protein turnover is ubiquitous. We also found that proteins sharing an E3 ligase can have closely related changes in their expression levels. These results imply that it may be difficult to interpret experimental results obtained from either overexpressing or knocking down protein levels, since changes in protein expression can be coupled via E3 ligase crosstalk. Understanding crosstalk and competition for E3 ligases will be key in ultimately developing a global picture of protein homeostasis.Author summaryPrevious work has shown that substrates of Post-Translational Modification (PTM) cycles can have coupled responses if those substrates share enzymes. This implies that modifications leading to substrate degradation (e.g. ubiquitylation by an E3 ligase) could introduce coupling in concentrations of substrates sharing a ligase. Using mathematical models, we found adding protein turnover to a PTM cycle diminishes both sensitivity and ultrasensitivity, particularly in models admitting long ubiquitin chains. We also found that proteins sharing an E3 ligase can indeed have coupled changes in both expression and sensitivity to signals. These results imply that accounting for crosstalk in protein degradation networks is crucial for the interpretation of results from a wide variety of common experimental perturbations to living systems.